Banana Toffee Pie Recipe

This Site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to

If you are looking for a unique and delcious dessert for your holiday celebrations or party, I’ve got the ticket for you, and it’s EASSSSY!  Before you click away because the title just sounds too odd…trust me, it’s delicious. There are so many amazing elements to this pie, that it’s just quite simply a showstopper. This Banana Toffee Pie Recipe is also called Banoffee pie, but I thought that just sounded too strange (and coffee-like, which I don’t drink), and I decided to simplify the title for my version of the recipe. It’s filled with luscious caramel on the inside, with a delightful whipped cream on top.

Banana Toffee Pie Recipe

Apparently Banoffee Pie a thing in England…like a famous recipe made a different way (and even has a history on wikipedia). I’d never heard of it before, and when my friend Heather brought it to a gathering recently, it didn’t necessarily scream, “EAT ME” just from the looks of it. But I wanted to give it a try, especially when she detailed all the yummy ingredients. One bite, and I was HOOKED!

Banana Toffee Banoffee Pie Recipe

Heather told me about the recipe for Banoffee Pie she found at Mel’s Kitchen Cafe. I mean, I’d heard of the gal…fellow blogger and all, but my friend says she loves and trusts all of her recipes, and I’m like…”Hmmm, interesting.” I’d since heard another friend say the same thing about Mel’s Kitchen Cafe, and I’m like “WOW, must check out her recipes.” When I made the pie myself about a week later, I changed up the recipe a bit to my liking, but used hers as a base.

Here are the ingredients at a glance:

Banana Toffee Banoffee Pie Recipe

Now, Mel used standard Oreo’s as her pie base, and I did the same. Traditional banoffee pie’s, I learned, often have a graham cracker or Nilla wafer type crust. Those sound delicious, too. Also, in other pies, the “offee” is for toffee (not coffee), which is often the filling. Mel went the extra step adding toffee bits on top, which I do not disapprove.  I had a hard time finding the chocolate covered toffee bits in my reg. store baking aisle, but Wal-Mart saved the day. Also, instead of using several elements to make the caramel type toffee middle layer, you can simply purchase the dulce de leche can in the baking aisle (see can above).

I also used heavy whipping cream to make the delicious whipped cream topping. In the past few years, we’ve preferred making our own whipping cream, it’s so much more creamy and delicious than the pre made freezer stuff.

Banana Toffee Banoffee Pie Recipe

I actually collaborated with Shamrock Farms premium Heavy Whipping Cream for this post, and I wanted to share a few fun facts about their product:

  • Shamrock Farms premium Heavy Whipping Cream is preferred by chefs for everything from rich sauces to decadent dressings, and is ideal for whipping as the higher butterfat leads to stronger peaks and longer hold times.
  • Shamrock Farms creams have a reputation for being rich and creamy because they’re made with real dairy from cows never treated with the growth hormone rBST.
  • Shamrock Farms creams lineup includes traditional half and half – with zero trans-fat and Shamrock Farms heavy cream, both with an easy to use flip top cap.

Banana Toffee Banoffee Pie Recipe

So you want the recipe? Yes, yes you do.

5.0 from 1 reviews
Banana Toffee Pie Recipe
Recipe type: dessert
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 10
  • Crust:
  • 24 Oreo's
  • 5 T butter, softened
  • Pie:
  • 1 can (12 oz) dulce de leche
  • 3 bananas
  • 2 cups chocolate covered toffee bits (entire bag)
  • 1.5 cups Shamrock Farms heavy whipping cream
  • ¼ cup powdered sugar
  • 8 ounces light or regular cream cheese, softened
  • ¼ cup brown sugar
  1. Process cookies and butter in blender.
  2. Press the mixture into the bottom and up the sides of a 9-inch pie plate.
  3. Put in freezer 10-15 minutes until set til firm.
  4. Spread the dulce de leche all over the chilled crust.
  5. Mix the powdered sugar, brown sugar and cream cheese with a mixer until smooth.
  6. Add the heavy whipping cream and mix until combined (careful to start slow so it doesn't splatter).
  7. Mix until the cream mixture is like frosting, thick, set aside.
  8. Slice the bananas and place them over the dulce de leche in the crust.
  9. Sprinkle about ½ cup toffee bits over the bananas.
  10. Spread the whipped cream frosting over the bananas and toffee, covering the bananas completely.
  11. Sprinkle the top of the pie with the remaining toffee bits.
  12. Chill for 3-4 hours before serving and up to 8 hours.


Banana Toffee Banoffee Pie Recipe

Just FYI, it’s best eaten the same day, due to the fresh nature of the bananas, but I finished my pie off for breakfast 2 days after I made it, and it was still just as delicious as it was the first day.

Banana Toffee Banoffee Pie Recipe

This is a sponsored conversation written by me on behalf of Shamrock Farms. The opinions and text are all mine.

Enjoy this fun sped up video of the steps!

Want a FREE copy of 10 Intentional Ways to Bring your Family Closer Together e-book? Enter your email below!

Powered by ConvertKit

Join The Discussion


Rate this recipe:  


  1. Delicious. I have definitely make this one. I am always excited to read this types of article.

  2. This pie sounds absolutely delicious!

  3. We love bananas and toffee together, so this is going to be a huge hit here!

  4. I might just make this for the holiday weekend! I think we’d love it!

  5. I love banana! This looks great!

  6. I could sit down and eat several pieces of this! SOOOOO good!

  7. Wonderful comfort food treat!!!

  8. SO many amazing elements in this pie!! Can’t wait to give it a try!!!

  9. Mmmm….toffee! This looks absolutely delicious!

  10. These are some seriously delicious ingredients!